Over the last few days, many people in the NBA and wider sports media world have settled on a basic talking point when discussing the ongoing international incident that Rockets GM Daryl Morey kicked off when he tweeted a message of support for pro-democracy protestors in Hong Kong: It’s complicated. But is it all that complicated?
The various social and historical factors motivating both the Hong Kong protestors and the Chinese government’s violent response to them are certainly complicated, but there’s not much haze covering the points at which the NBA intersects this story. Is the question of whether one should feel sympathy for demonstrators who are being teargassed and beaten in the streets a complicated one? What about the question of whether an authoritarian government should attempt to censor and financially harm an American sports league over a single tweet?
Despite the easy answers to those questions, a fog of uncertainty and hesitation has been thrown over so many discussions of the NBA’s relationship with China. It seems to me that everyone took their cues from Nets owner Joe Tsai, who in a lengthy Facebook post insisted that in order to understand the damage Morey’s tweet did to a nation of 1.4 billion people, you have to understand the history of the Opium Wars, the Qing dynasty, and the Massacre of Nanjing. He wrote:
The one thing that is terribly misunderstood, and often ignored, by the western press and those critical of China is that 1.4 billion Chinese citizens stand united when it comes to the territorial integrity of China and the country’s sovereignty over her homeland. This issue is non-negotiable.
The sleight of hand here—which, as Slate’s Tom Scocca pointed out, is one routinely deployed in propaganda campaigns—should be obvious. Tsai is attributing the anger that the Chinese government and a few powerful corporations felt at the NBA to the Chinese population at large. This makes the backlash against Morey and the league not only seem more organic, but far more valid. If the GM of the Rockets really did piss off an entire country, who are any of us to say anything about it?
Plenty were eager to follow Tsai’s lead. Sports writers rushed to Twitter and television to let everyone know that the wisest course of action is to just steer clear of this complicated issue. The Athletic’s Joe Vardon wrote an explainer on the crisis that took Tsai’s comments at face value, and quoted someone from a think tank established to advocate for the Chinese government’s claims to the South China Sea. Steve Kerr said he needed to talk to his brother, a professor of Chinese history, before he could comment on the situation.
Perhaps nobody was more snowed in than The Ringer’s Bill Simmons, who on a podcast with the Wall Street Journal’s Jason Gay worried that angry protesto
The Lakers and Nets did end up playing on Thursday, and aside from a total lack of sponsorship logos and a government-mandated lack of press availability, a normal basketball game unfolded. Here’s how ESPN described the scene:
Many of the capacity crowd of 18,000 entered the arena toting hand-held Chinese flags that were being distributed outside. Before the starting lineups were announced, there was no singing of the national anthem — not the American “Star-Spangled Banner” nor the Chinese “March of the Volunteers.”
But it wasn’t completely foreign.
Whatever unrest existed in the days leading up to the game was not reflected by the crowd during pregame warm-ups, as cheers erupted in the stands with every
James continued to elicit adulation once play started, receiving boisterous approval after scoring the first bucket of the game on a layup and later hearing “MVP!” chants when shooting free throws during the first quarter.
The vibe inside the arena seems to have been no different from any other NBA game:
If it’s hard to square the image of two NBA teams walking into a Shanghai arena unmolested and playing a game in front of thousands of cheering fans with the supposed nationwide antagonism currently being directed at the NBA, maybe that’s because this story all far less complicated than Tsai and so many others have been insisting it is.
Morey certainly pissed off a good number of Chinese citizens with his tweet, but every year the NBA plays games in cities full of people who
- Why are so many pre-existing IPs turning to TV? It’s complicated
- Kobe Bryant's complicated legacy sparks tough conversations
- Why We Can’t Stop Watching Keanu Reeves, 30 Years On
- Chace Crawford finally addresses
- Google photos will automatically mail your best photos to you for $8/month
- Missing the World Cup Is Like Detention for the United States
- STATE OF THE NATION: We ‘re in a state of emergency — Oritsejafor
- Why the White House Correspondents’ Dinner Should Go On
- : We’re Lovin’ It
- HIV discoverer: 'To develop a cure is almost impossible'
- In the Room Where It Happens, Eight Shows a Week
- Matthew McConaughey, Janelle Monáe, Michelle Williams and More Oscar Contenders Break Down Their Toughest Scenes
- Exclusive: Alfredo Morelos talks discipline and life at Rangers
- Spec Sheet: comparing the Xbox One, PlayStation 4, and Wii U
- Madonna, Mercy and Malawi: her fight to adopt a second African child
- The Most Emotional Speeches on
- Recap: Suit and Tie
- Seattle NHL franchise responds to rumors about selecting 'Kraken' as team name
- ‘Everybody Was Bawling’: Kristen Bell on the End of ‘The Good Place’
- Atlanta Spent $2.6M to Recover From a $52,000 Ransomware Scare
Maybe It's Not That Complicated have 920 words, post on deadspin.com at October 10, 2019. This is cached page on Talk Vietnam. If you want remove this page, please contact us.