- All Topics
Europe and AfricaExternal RelationsFood and AgricultureGame ParksGovernanceHealthHuman RightsICTInfrastructureInnovationInternational OrganisationsInvestmentLabourLand and Rural IssuesLatin America and AfricaLegal AffairsMalariaManufacturingMediaMiddle East and AfricaMigrationMiningMusicMusic ReviewsNCDsNGONutrition
- All Topics
South Africa: New Healthcare Plan Promises to Overhaul South Africa’s Massively Skewed SystemZimbabwe: Man Allegedly Rapes, Infects Daughter With HIVAfrica: New & Resurgent Infectious Diseases Can Have Far-Reaching Economic RepercussionsTanzania: Why Rayvanny Wants Philanderer Diamond Platnumz to Take a HIV Test
South Africa: Lower June Cash-in-Transit Stats No Comfort – FidelitySouth Africa: Group Calling On Uber Drivers to Go Offline Causing ‘Unnecessary Unrest’ – UberAfrica: How Young Activists Are Keeping Mandela’s Legacy Alive Across AfricaSouth Africa: Lions Kill Suspected Poachers in Private Game Reserve
History repeats as old health emergencies emerge anew. Is the health ombud the person to lead fights the Human Rights Commission started?
It’s a May morning in 2018 and cancer activists, journalists and politicians are seated around a fluorescent-lit conference room at the offices of the South African Human Rights Commission (SAHRC) in Braamfontein, Johannesburg.
A lone broadcast camera is angled towards the table in the centre of the room and representatives of the KwaZulu-Natal health department take their seats, flanked by their legal team.
The department’s acting head of health and chief executive of Durban’s Inkosi Albert Luthuli Central Hospital nervously set up their computers. It’s been almost a year since Durban lost its last state oncologist and more than two years since the SAHRC began investigating collapsing cancer services in the province.
But someone is missing. KwaZulu-Natal’s health MEC Sibongiseni Dhlomo. The honourable MEC will be late, his legal counsel explains.
“Unbelievable,” tuts a disgruntled Imran Keeka, the Democratic Alliance’s spokesperson for health in KwaZulu-Natal. It was Keeka’s complaint to the SAHRC that launched an inquiry into the province’s oncology services. The commission would later find that the health department violated cancer patients’ right to health by failing to care for them.
It would be another two years before Dhlomo appeared before the commission at their Johannesburg office block, earlier this year. By that time, at least 500 cancer patients had died in state hospital beds awaiting treatment.
The SAHRC was established in 1995 under the Human Rights Commission Act to promote, protect and monitor human rights. The commission is one of eight bodies established in terms of Chapter Nine of the Constitution.
Under the Act, the commission has the power to investigate human rights violations, subpoena people to appear before it and make recommendations for redress although these aren’t legally binding. The body can, however, sue parties that don’t implement recommendations, says Sasha Stevenson, the head of health at legal nonprofit Section27.
In recent years, the human rights commission has received complaints about everything from a lack of mobile clinics to KwaZulu-Natal’s crumbling cancer services. Headlines decrying the state of South Africa’s public health sector have reached a fever pitch, leading citizens and opposition parties alike to turn to the SAHRC. But the commission’s health investigations have yielded mixed results. As the body navigates a new terrain of scarce funds and an uncertain future, some organisations are placing their hope in the country’s new health ombud.
The commission investigated several major health inquiries – three in the last two decades – into conditions at Lindela Repatriation Centre for undocumented migrants. The body found that officials at the Krugersdorp facility outside Johannesburg denied detainees proper nutrition and adequate access to HIV and tuberculosis (TB) medicine. Meanwhile, the commission found that overcrowding at Lindela made conditions there ripe for the transmission of TB.
Similarly the watchdog has twice interrogated the availability of ambulances – nationally in 2007 and in the Eastern Cape in 2013. The commission found the province violated patients’ right to emergency medical care by providing less than half of the vehicles required by national health department standards.
Guidelines say there should be one ambulance for every 10 000 people. The Eastern Cape had just 300 working ambulances when the SAHRC began its investigation, a 2015 commission hearing report showed.
Section27 is part of the civil society Eastern Cape Health Crisis Coalition, which was a complainant in the Eastern Cape hearing. In the two years since the commission’s hearing report, Stevenson says there have been some improvements.
The provincial health department has bought 140 new ambulances and eradicated the understaffed “one-man” ambulance crews as the commission recommended.
“An ambulance with only a driver is just a taxi with a stretcher. You need someone to provide care while you’re going,” she explains.
But Stevenson argues the province’s emergency medical services are still inefficient.
“You can call an ambulance, and it might come. But only four to six hours later,” she says.
“You still can’t rely on the system.”
The commission’s recommendation that the province trains rural community members to provide first aid at least in the absence of better EMS has gone unimplemented.
Stevenson says when the commission was asked why it had not done more to track whether the province had acted on its recommendations, its Eastern Cape office said: “We didn’t have the budget.”
Health conditions at Lindela Repatriation Centre for undocumented migrants remain dangerous despite South African Human Rights Commission investigations spanning two decades. (Paul Botes)
Starting this year, the treasury will slash the commission’s budget by about R5-million annually until 2021, according to treasury data. This leaves only R3.2-million for the SAHRC to fulfil its constitutional mandate in 2018, the commission’s spokesperson Gail Smith, says. Money for investigations, hearings, litigation and human rights monitoring are all paid from this purse. Chief executive Tseliso Thipanyane says treasury told the commission that the cuts were partly to fund free higher education.
Funding to implement the National Health Insurance (NHI) scheme will also increase by more than R4-billion until 2021, treasury data shows.
Thipanyane explains: “We are a small organisation. Almost 75% of our budget goes to salaries.
“If nothing changes, we could be forced to retrench.”
Thipanyane says the government could be deliberately strangling the body. “Those who exercise power typically do not want to be held to account.”
The Chapter Nine institution’s shrinking budget is not enough to prove it is being stifled. Cabinet also approved R85-billion in budget cuts this year across all government departments, says treasury spokesperson Zwikhodo Singo.
Alison Tilley, the head of advocacy at the social and economic justice nonprofit the Open Democracy Advice Centre, argues that the way commissioners are recruited is a bigger worry than inevitably shrinking budgets.
The ANC’s deployment committee vets candidates before their appointment to senior positions in Chapter Nine institutions.
“That in itself is a strangling of these institutions. Candidates should not be vetted by the majority party,” she says
Uncertainty about what the future holds for Chapter Nines could also be keeping the watchdogs on a leash, Tilley says. In 2007, a committee led by late ANC stalwart Kader Asmal recommended that five of the eight institutions be merged into one human rights protector.
But more than a decade later, no plans have been announced. “There is no clarity on where these institutions will be five years from now,” Tilley warns.
Meanwhile, the number of public complaints regarding violations of the right to health has increased by nearly 45% since 2016, according to SAHRC annual reports. The commission received 641 such complaints in 2017, second in number only to those regarding equality.
By comparison, the recently created Office of Health Standards Compliance (OHSC) received at least 730 complaints in the first eight months of establishing a national call centre, according to the OHSC 2016/17 annual report. The OHSC and its ombud were created in part to monitor the quality of health services. The flood of calls followed the health ombud’s high-profile investigation and damning report on the Life Esidimeni tragedy in which 144 mental health patients lost their lives after being removed from long-term, state-funded care at private Life Esidimeni facilities.
The ombud – and not the commission for a change – may also be the latest to take over investigations into health services at the Lindela Repatriation Centre.
In 2017, the Democratic Alliance alleged that the South African Human Rights Commission could have stopped the Life Esidimeni deaths had it acted swiftly. (Oupa Nkosi)
Over the past 15 years, the commissions’ many investigations into Lindela have uncovered not only inadequate medical care at the facility but also the illegal detention of migrant children. Complaints filed by the public interest litigation organisation Lawyers for Human Rights (LHR) and international humanitarian organisation Doctors Without Borders (MSF) prompted a 2012 interrogation at the centre. Subsequently, the pair gained very limited access to Lindela to conduct oversight visits through the commission. Almost half of 35 recommendations made by the trio to improve health services and conditions at Lindela have not been implemented, according to a 2017 MSF document.
After witnessing the dire conditions at Lindela, MSF proposed to station a medical team at Lindela’s clinic. The group would train doctors and nurses at the clinic to assess detainees for TB, HIV and other conditions.
“Proper screening is needed to ensure the clinic is not illegally admitting children – none of this is happening at Lindela,” MSF medical co-ordinator Amir Shroufi told Bhekisisa in December 2017.
South Africa’s own national strategic plan on HIV and TB requires that the country prioritise ways to stop TB transmission in detention settings. The strategy also calls for greater co-ordination between southern African countries to ensure that migrants can access HIV care. South Africa already provides HIV and TB medication to anyone in the country regardless of documentation.
But MSF’s proposal relied on the commission negotiating access to Lindela on its behalf. Ultimately, it failed to do so.
In December, Smith said that although the commission was supportive of MSF’s aims, they were “not fully aligned with the monitoring focus and support envisaged by the Commission”.
She added that the need for the commission to “present its own concerns to the new political leadership of the department” also impacted on its ability to get approval for MSF to access the facility long-term. At the time, the department of home affairs had just undergone its fifth change in minister in as many years.
As a result, MSF has now turned to the OHSC, submitting a complaint about care at Lindela in late June.
“The OHSC has acted decisively in the past where there has been a lack of oversight – this is needed for the clinic at Lindela,” says Garret Barnwell, who was part of the MSF team that conducted the latest assessment of Lindela.
In 2016, the health ombud Malegapuru Makgoba released a damning report into the circumstances around the deaths of almost 100 mental health patients who had been removed from state-funded private Life Esidimeni healthcare facilities. Stevenson argues that the success of Makgoba’s intervention is a prime example that state watchdogs’ effectiveness depends on the quality of their leadership – and the willingness of government leadership to respond.
At least 144 patients died as part of the Life Esidimeni tragedy. Families of 135 patients involved were awarded R1.18-million in damages as part of the arbitration. The National Prosecuting Authority is still considering possible criminal prosecutions related to the doomed move.
The SAHRC received a complaint about the transfers in March 2016, but did not respond until August, just weeks before former health MEC Qedani Mahlangu disclosed that 36 mental health patients died at mostly unregistered nonprofits. A subsequent ombud report would reveal that the actual death toll was almost double that at the time when Mahlangu presented the data to the Gauteng provincial legislature.
“Lives could have been saved if the commission acted seriously,” the DA’s shadow health MEC in Gauteng Jack Bloom said in a 2017 statement. The SAHRC has since appointed a new commission for health matters.
Although Thipanyane admits the Commission has not sufficiently followed up on recommendations it has made in the past, Smith argues government’s failure to comply with them is the real threat to the commission’s effectivity.
But when state departments refuse to implement recommendations – whether about ambulances, detention facilities or even KwaZulu-Natal’s current cancer crisis – both Stevenson and Smith say going to court isn’t always the answer.
The body has increased its litigation efforts by 32% since 2013. In 2016/17 alone, the SAHRC instituted 62 new litigation cases.
But legal action can take years to finalise and budget constraints force the commission to tread carefully before using scarce public resources, Smith says. The commission’s CEO Thipanyane admits the body will likely avoid the courts in future to accommodate a smaller budget.
“We can’t spend two years in courts to deal with a single human rights violation. We just don’t have the money.”
Beauty Zulu, a cervical cancer patient, was forced to wait months when oncology services in KwaZulu-Natal ground to a halt in 2016. (Madelene Cronje)
At the commission’s May hearing into collapsing oncology services in his province, KwaZulu-Natal health MEC Sibongiseni Dhlomo finally came face-to-face with commissioners. He had been subpoenaed to appear after repeatedly failing to meet SAHRC deadlines to improve oncology care in the province.
In a three-hour hearing, the man responsible for health in the province testified for about 10 minutes.
The health department bombarded the commission with data at the last minute, says the main complainant and DA MPL Imran Keeka. This, he claims, allowed Dhlomo to divert the conversation to issues that had already been resolved.
“It’s worrying that they failed to question him properly,” Stevenson says.
Although it may be time consuming and expensive to use the might of the law, the SAHRC – and other Chapter Nine institutions – have huge powers to request information and conduct inspections.
“It’s easier to get to the bottom of things through the Commission than through the courts,” she says.
There are no guarantees in court: “As the person bringing the case, you have to hope the other side provides information that will be useful to you.
The commission will now compile a hearing report, which in the case of the Eastern Cape EMS hearing took about six months.
In the case of KwaZulu-Natal’s oncology collapse, the Commission was bound by its own policies to give the department sufficient time to redeem itself after it failed to meet the watchdog’s deadlines.
“Seeking redress for human rights violations takes time,” Smith says.
The party is now also expected to turn to both the OHSC and public protector in a bid to help solve KZN’s oncology emergency but also other health crises across the country.
“We encouraged the commission to prosecute but that wasn’t done,” Keeka says.
“We want to see justice done for the families of those that have died in the crisis, which MEC Dhlomo has presided over.”
Have something to say? Tweet or Facebook us on @Bhekisisa_MG
President Cyril Ramaphosa cancelled his community meeting in Chatsworth to meet with King Zwelithini on Friday night. Read more »
See What Everyone is Watching
Copyright © 2018 Bhekisisa. All rights reserved. Distributed by AllAfrica Global Media (allAfrica.com). To contact the copyright holder directly for corrections — or for permission to republish or make other authorized use of this material, click here.
AllAfrica publishes around 800 reports a day from more than 140 news organizations and over 500 other institutions and individuals, representing a diversity of positions on every topic. We publish news and views ranging from vigorous opponents of governments to government publications and spokespersons. Publishers named above each report are responsible for their own content, which AllAfrica does not have the legal right to edit or correct.
- Zimbabwe: Man Allegedly Rapes, Infects Daughter With HIV
- Tanzania: Why Rayvanny Wants Philanderer Diamond Platnumz to Take a HIV Test
- Malawi: Chiefs Appeal for Stiffer Penalties Against People Misusing Nets
- South Africa: MEC Magome Masike – Press Conference On Health Services
- South Africa: Your Basic Right to Minimum Medical Benefits
- South Africa: How Your Health Issues Are Manipulated to Serve the Interests of Big Medical Business
- Egypt: Sisi Directs to Continue Development of Health Sector in Egypt
- South Africa: Health Workers Say They Are Undervalued and Poorly Equipped
- Tanzania: What Tanzania Is Doing to Enhance Cancer Treatment – Minister
- South Africa: Cape Town Residents Wait Days for Ambulance
- Zimbabwe: Unemployed Teachers, Nurses to Get Jobs – VP Chiwenga
- Rwanda: How Access to ARVs Became a Right in Rwanda
- Mauritius: MRA Launches Its Annual Blood Donation Campaign
- Nigeria: U.S. Commits $5.1 Billion to HIV/Aids in Nigeria
- Nigeria: Do 10 Nigerians Die From Cancer Every Hour?
- Nigeria: Nigeria to Be 24 Months Free of Polio in August – WHO
Condom Exposes Promiscuous Kenyan Man
More Hands on Deck For Healthy Hearts
One Dead, More Infected as Swine Flu Outbreak Hits Namibia
Investigation After Woman Found Alive in South African Morgue
DR Congo Health Minister Speaks on ‘Control’ of Ebola Outbreak
Sexual Harassment in the Spotlight at Equal Education Congress
With Refrigerated ATMs, Camel Milk Business Thrives in Kenya
Free Blood for Zimbabwe’s Public Hospitals
New Drive to Develop Drugs in Africa to Fight Malaria, TB
Reports of Swine Flu Outbreak in Namibia
Nigeria Looks to Quality Health Care to End Medical Tourism
Why Uganda Should Confront Sex in Prisons
How to Stop Deadly Lead Poisoning in Nigeria – Govt
Why Malawians With Albinism Are Running for President in 2019
Can a New Typhoid Vaccine End Nigeria’s Most Misdiagnosed Disease
Kenyatta Flags Off 100 Cuban Doctors to Counties
Study Shows How A Vaccine Can Reverse Type 1 Diabetes
MSF Comments After Former Staff Speak of Sexual Misconduct
Health Dept ‘Rot’ Zuma Kept Hidden Revealed to South Africa
South African Minister Unveils Universal Healthcare Bills
Is Africa Better Prepared for Ebola?
Overcoming Infertility Through In Vitro Fertilization In Nigeria
What Are Noncommunicable Diseases and Their Risk Factors?
What If the Nurse Delivers Your Baby With Dirty Hands?
South Africa Hailed for ‘Revolutionary’ Step in Treating TB
Namibia Sees Drop in HIV-Aids Deaths
How Tech Can Help Win Fight Against Neglected Tropical Diseases
More From: Bhekisisa
- South Africa: Power and Crisis – Why SA’s Watchdogs Are More Bark Than Bite
- South Africa: Why Rape Counselling Needs to Hit the Road
- South Africa: Will the NHI Actually Work?
- South Africa: What the National Health Insurance Means for You & Your Pocket
- South Africa: Former Health Chief Responds to Explosive Corruption Findings
- South Africa: Read Brian Hlongwa’s Response to the SIU Report
- South Africa: Five Things the Gauteng Health Department Spent Your Money On – SIU
- South Africa: Health Workers’ Right to Refuse Abortions v Women’s Right to Choose
- South Africa: Limos & Spas – SIU Reveals Details of ANC Chief Whip Hlongwa’s Role in R1.2 Billion Graft
- South Africa: Health Department Expects to Be Sued Over Proposed NHI Changes
- Africa: Eight Ways to Make HIV Stories Meaningful
- South Africa: Your Medical Aid Is Going to Change. Read Aaron Motsoaledi’s #NHI Speech
- Lesotho: Not a School in Sight – Autistic Children Travel 500 Km to Learn
- Central African Republic: Widows – ‘I Was Kicked Out of Our House By His Parents’
- Mauritania: The Unspeakable Truth About Slavery in Mauritania
- Liberia: After Ebola – What Happens Next?
- Nigeria: Old Birth Rites, New Ways
- South Africa: ‘We Are Forced to Move On From Declaring Babies Dead As If Nothing Happens’
- South Africa: ‘My Hands Are Tied’ – Says Health Minister Motsoaledi
- South Africa: ‘Health System Is Not Collapsing’ – Motsoaledi
- South Africa: Burning Tyres and Dodgy Ambulance Deals? Six Health Scandals You Might Have Missed
- South Africa: How the ACDP Peddled Unproven Facts in Its Bid to Tighten SA’s Abortion Laws
- South Africa: ‘Cancer Treatment in the North West Is Impossible’
- South Africa: Award-Winning Pontsho Pilane – Here’s Why Beat Reporting Matters
- South Africa: Durban Cuts City’s Only Needle Exchange Programme
- Africa: Speak More Than One Language? This Is What It Does to Your Brain.
- South Africa: When Elephants Fight – ‘Supra Mahumapelo Killed My Sister’
- Mali: Football’s Dashed Hopes – the Teenagers Sold a Premier League Lie
- South Africa: Cancer Crisis – Where Are the Radiation Oncologists?
- Congo-Kinshasa: The Testing Ground – Could an Experimental Vaccine Save the DRC From Ebola?
- South Africa: Why Is This 290-Bed North West Hospital Catering for Just 19 Patients?
- South Africa: Limpopo, Mpumalanga Without Radiation Oncologists As National Cancer Crisis Deepens
- Nigeria: Banks to Tighten Loan Conditions Amidst Increased Lending Activities(Vanguard)
- Zimbabwe: Govt Fails to Curb Profligacy(Zimbabwe Independent)
- South Africa: South African Reserve Bank Briefs Media On VBS Mutual Bank, 9 Jul(Govt of SA)
- Zimbabwe: ‘Economy On Growth Trajectory’(The Herald)
- Ghana: Builsa Community Bank Profitability Improves(Ghanaian Times)
- Zimbabwe: Capital Bank Liquidation in Limbo(Zimbabwe Independent)
- Kenya: KBC Managers Shock Senators With Revelation of Sh7 Billion Loss(Nairobi News)
- Tanzania: Agriculture Bank Issues U.S.$440 Million to Farmers(Citizen)
- Zimbabwe: ‘Ballooning Real Time Gross Settlement Indicate Lack of Lending’(The Herald)
- Zimbabwe: Women’s Bank Warns Against Fraudsters(263Chat)
- Ethiopia: Ogaden Basin – Source of Peril or Prosperity for the Somali Region?(Addis Standard)
- Ethiopia: Ethiopia Considers Building Oil Terminal in Djibouti(Reporter)
- Uganda: Uganda Petroleum Institute to Get University Status(Oil in Uganda)
- Kenya: Turkana Oil Standoff – Leaders Declare Truce After Talks(Nation)
- South Africa: Economic Cluster On Increasing Fuel Prices(Govt of SA)
- Tanzania: Anxiety Mounts in Tanzanian As Global Oil Prices Soar(Citizen)
- Rwanda: Fuel Prices Further Revised Upwards(New Times)
- Uganda: New Fuel Tax Pushes Fares Up(Monitor)
- Namibia: Fuel Levy Increases(Namibian)
- Nigeria: Oil Communities Allege Neglect By Govt(Guardian)
- South Africa: Uber Drivers Plead for Fare Hike Following Petrol Price Increase(News24Wire)
- Tanzania: Magufuli to Receive Tanzania’s First Ever Boeing 787 Dreamliner(Citizen)
- South Africa: Group Calling On Uber Drivers to Go Offline Causing ‘Unnecessary Unrest’ – Uber(News24Wire)
- South Africa: Suspected Robber Shot Dead in High-Speed Joburg Car Chase(News24Wire)
- Kenya: Michael Kamau Charged Anew Over Sh33m Road Tender Award(Nation)
- South Africa: Train Fire Causes Delays in Cape Town(News24Wire)
- Nigeria: Experts Flay Proposed National Carrier Project(This Day)
- Kenya: KQ Female Pilot Denies Reports She’ll Fly Maiden Flight to U.S.(Nairobi News)
- Tanzania: Container Handling to Rise By 20% This Year – TICTS(Citizen)
- Kenya: Sultan Hamud Crash – Odinga Accused of Being Out of Touch(Nairobi News)
- Africa: Clinics Manage Hypertension Patients Better When More Hands Are On Deck(The Conversation Africa)
- South Africa: New Healthcare Plan Promises to Overhaul South Africa’s Massively Skewed System(The Conversation Africa)
- Zimbabwe: Man Allegedly Rapes, Infects Daughter With HIV(The Herald)
- South Africa: Power and Crisis – Why SA’s Watchdogs Are More Bark Than Bite(Bhekisisa)
- Africa: New & Resurgent Infectious Diseases Can Have Far-Reaching Economic Repercussions(IPS)
- Tanzania: Why Rayvanny Wants Philanderer Diamond Platnumz to Take a HIV Test(Nairobi News)
- Nigeria: U.S. Commits $5.1 Billion to HIV/Aids in Nigeria(Premium Times)
- Malawi: Chiefs Appeal for Stiffer Penalties Against People Misusing Nets(Malawi News Agency)
- South Africa: MEC Magome Masike – Press Conference On Health Services(Govt of SA)
- South Africa: Your Basic Right to Minimum Medical Benefits(Daily Maverick)
- Uganda: Activist Stella Nyanzi Collapses While Visiting Suspects(Monitor)
- Africa: Google’s Project Loon Balloons to Beam High-Speed Internet to Rural Africa(This is Africa)
- East Africa: World Economic Forum Names CarePay 2018 Technology Pioneer(CIO)
- East Africa: KDDI, Samsung Successfully Complete Live Real-Time Free-Viewpoint Video Stream Test On 5G(CIO)
- Africa: New Provision Made in .africa Domain Names for Resellers(CIO)
- Tanzania: TTCL Mulls More Services As It Seeks to Boost Income(Citizen)
- Africa: Cybercrime Legislation in the GCC Countries – Fit for Purpose?(Chatham House)
- Ghana: Yolanda Cuba Is CEO of the Year(Ghanaian Times)
- Africa: Durban July Features Africa’s First 5G Sport Broadcast(CAJ News)
- Africa: Mobile 360 Africa Speakers Confirmed(CAJ News)
- Ethiopia: Years of Untold Suffering at Jail Ogaden(HRW)
- Western Sahara: Call for Attaching Greater Importance to Human Rights Situation(SPS)
- Angola: Journalists’ Acquittal a Victory for Free Speech in Angolan(HRW)
- Burundi: School Ban On Expectant Teens ‘Skewed’ Against Girls’ Education(Thomson Reuters Foundation)
- South Africa: Power and Crisis – Why SA’s Watchdogs Are More Bark Than Bite(Bhekisisa)
- Uganda: It’s Men Who Cause Rape, Not Clothes(East African)
- Libya: Head of Migration Body Arrives to Advocate for Migrants’ Rights(Africa Renewal)
- Mali: UN Expert Urges Prompt Investigation of ‘Alarming’ Rights Violations(Africa Renewal)
- Kenya: Embobut Forest – the Only Home the Sengwer Know(Nation)
- South Africa: ‘Dispossessed’ Urban Poor Call for Land Reform(Thomson Reuters Foundation)
AllAfrica is a voice of, by and about Africa – aggregating, producing and distributing 800 news and information items daily from over 140 African news organizations and our own reporters to an African and global public. We operate from Cape Town, Dakar, Abuja, Monrovia, Nairobi and Washington DC.
- Coronavirus in South Africa: Eight lessons for the rest of the continent
- Coronavirus chaos: Inside South Africa's 'hospitals of horrors'
- South Africa loosens lockdown in economic recovery effort
- Jacob Zuma breached constitution over home upgrades, South African court rules
- Then and now: rising through crisis will always be England's rugby ritual
- Kenyan Netflix exec on producing during a pandemic and amplifying Africa's creative potential
South Africa: Power and Crisis have 4838 words, post on allafrica.com at July 6, 2018. This is cached page on Talk Vietnam. If you want remove this page, please contact us.