Eric D. Lawrence Detroit Free Press
Published 10:00 p.m. UTC Jun 27, 2018
Elon Musk has called lidar a crutch.
The Tesla CEO believes he can build self-driving and semi-autonomous cars without relying on the technology, which uses lasers to help the cars map and navigate their surroundings.
Instead, Tesla has looked to cameras and radar — without lidar — to do much of the work needed for its Autopilot driver assistance system.
But other automakers and tech companies rushing to develop autonomous cars — Waymo, Ford and General Motors, for instance — are betting on lidar.
In a posting on Medium last year, Karl Vogt, CEO of GM’s Cruise Automation, wrote that “Lidar sensors contribute to the redundancy and overlapping capabilities needed to build a car that operates without a driver, even in the most challenging environments.”
Many industry watchers believe lidar is an essential part of developing safe self-driving systems. Lidar, also known as light detection and ranging, is typically seen as a device spinning atop an autonomous vehicle.
“I think you absolutely need all three types (cameras, lidar and radar) because each one has strengths and weaknesses,” said Sam Abuelsamid, an analyst with Navigant Research. Abuelsamid pointed to a camera’s ability, for instance, to recognize objects but its difficulty in seeing in certain dark and light conditions. Lidar, on the other hand, bounces lasers off an object to create an image, potentially avoiding the lighting issue even as rain and snow could limit its effectiveness.
Because of those strengths and weaknesses, each technology offers a level of redundancy, which Abuelsamid and others believe is needed.
“Tesla’s trying to do it on the cheap,” Abuelsamid said. “They’re trying to take the cheap approach and focus on software. The problem with software is it’s only as good as the data you can feed it.”
Tesla’s approach on lidar has raised questions in light of some recent crashes involving cars in Autopilot mode, although it’s not clear that lidar would have made a difference.
Tesla declined to comment on the subject.
David Liniado, Cox Automotive’s vice president for new growth and development, has experience with Tesla’s Autopilot because he drives a Model X.
“I think it’s the safest cruise control that there is, their Autopilot, and I think it’s a game changer,” Liniado said.
Cost, he said, is likely what motivated Musk’s comments on lidar.
With prices estimated as high as $75,000 per vehicle in recent years, it’s not difficult to see why. But those in the industry say prices will come down dramatically in the future.
Mitch Hourtienne, director of business development for lidar startup Cepton, predicted at a lidar conference this month in Ypsilanti that the company eventually could get its price below $200.
Velodyne, the most established player in the lidar space, announced previously that it was cutting the costs on some of its sensors to about $4,000, and Ouster, whose CEO and co-founder Angus Pacala was also at the conference, says it has a lidar unit available for $3,500.
Lower prices are important because consumers will not necessarily be willing to pay extra for lidar, Hourtienne said, noting that carmakers must sell consumers on the technology’s benefits regarding safety. GM’s Vogt, in the Medium post, said the company’s acquisition of Strobe, a lidar startup, would help it reduce the cost of lidar on its self-driving cars by 99 percent.
At the conference, representatives of Velodyne, Ouster and other companies such as Blackmore, Innoviz and TetraVue joined Hourtienne in discussing their approaches to the technology and how they were working to make lidar units small enough not to be noticeable as well as reduce the cost of the units.
During his talk, Hourtienne showed a display with a white vehicle moving on a street, an example of how lidar can map an area. He could point to images of a bicyclist and pedestrian moving, as well as a dark bubble immediately around the vehicle, showing where the lidar was not focused.
That display was one of several a Free Press reporter saw during the conference, including during driving demonstrations on public roads around the hotel where the conference was being held. The displays showed computer-generated images of objects in a range of colors that were easy enough to decipher.
Self-driving tech supplier Velodyne cuts price of key sensor in half
How a semi-autonomous Nissan Rogue made me a safer, better driver
Aditya Srinivasan, general manager for North America for Innoviz, used a ball to demonstrate in the simplest of terms how lidar works, dropping the ball to the ground to show how the device would send light, or lasers, out to bounce against objects and measure the time of flight in order to create an image map.
Srinivasan, who said his company would be providing lidar units for various BMW vehicles in coming years, said in an autonomous vehicle, “the machine must perceive its environment much better than you or I can.”
It’s important to have a perceptive machine because of the risk inherent in creating robots that can travel on the roads at high speeds, he said.
Liniado of Cox Automotive, whose company has invested in Ouster, said lidar has the ability to boost autonomous vehicle development because of what it can do, and if prices do drop, it could begin to make economic sense in certain circumstances.
“As a centerpiece of data collection for mapping, it brings a level of data extraction … we’ve never seen before because it can literally map a crack in the road,” Liniado said.
One of the main issues going forward for lidar and other aspects of autonomous vehicle development could be a lack of standards for the technology. Abuelsamid noted that more potential problems are likely to emerge as additional autonomous and semi-autonomous vehicles begin testing on public roads.
Based on the Trump administration’s aversion to regulations, the onus of such an effort would likely fall to the auto industry and the states, Abuelsamid said, declaring that states should require testing before releasing the vehicles onto the roads.
When asked if additional crashes are likely to happen before action is taken, Abuelsamid said that “unfortunately that’s probably what it will take.”
Contact Eric D. Lawrence: [email protected] Follow him on Twitter: @_ericdlawrence.
- Watch out, Tesla: Waymo says it may soon test its self-driving technology in trucks
- Elon Musk Twitter rant a 'case study' in how not to handle a crisis, experts say
- Oil exec accused of impersonating Elon Musk to steal Tesla's company secrets
- Elon Musk declares on Twitter that he has a 'top secret Tesla masterplan'
- Elon Musk Provides Sneak Peek Of Elevator For Underground Tunnel Project
- Elon Musk Holds Pod Competition To Showcase Underground Tunnel Idea
- Elon Musk Claims Project Will Hook Your Brain Directly to Computer by 2020
- Elon Musk says older Tesla models can soon get a free self-driving chip upgrade
- Why Elon Musk picked Germany not the UK for Tesla's Europe gigafactory
- Tesla to build first European gigafactory in Germany, Elon Musk announces
- Elon Musk posts new update on 'Starship' ahead of launch
- Battle of the billionaires: Elon Musk takes on Jack Ma in debate over the future of AI
- The race to make Elon Musk's vision of a 700mph hyperloop a reality in Europe
- Ford and VW now own an equal stake in Argo AI, the self-driving car startup
- Volkswagen Group to collaborate with self-driving firm Aurora Innovation
- Elon Musk Hypes Tesla Insurance and Batteries, Backs Off Robotaxi Claims
- Elon Musk's Boring Company wins its bid to build tunnels that will allow 150mph 'electric skates' to transport people between downtown Chicago and O'Hare Airport
- Wooing Tesla: Eastern Germans vie for Elon Musk's attention
- Elon Musk says Tesla will build a European Gigafactory outside of Berlin
- Oops! Autonomous robot struck and 'killed' by a self-driving Tesla in Las Vegas ahead of CES
Is Tesla's Elon Musk wrong about this key self-driving technology? have 1302 words, post on eu.freep.com at June 27, 2018. This is cached page on Talk Vietnam. If you want remove this page, please contact us.