No one was surprised last week when news broke that a small-town school without a sex education program was teeming with chlamydia. Unfortunately, that story has proven to be false, leaving a tiny Texas town traumatized with embarrassment over an error reported as fact by the school’s superintendent.
Vice reports that after Jim Rumage sent home a notice stating that 20 students had contracted chlamydia (that’s about one in 15 for the school), national news media descended upon Crane, Texas to report what was going on. The Centers for Disease Control referred to such an epidemic as “reaching epic proportions,” and all across the country people (like us) shook their heads at what a lack of education could do. But Rumage, who told Vice he thought he was “acting prudently” made one fatal error: He wrote to parents that 20 students had contracted the disease when actually 21 students had been tested for it. The actual number of students affected, three, hardly qualifies as an outbreak.
While it’s upsetting that the small town has been showered with negative attention—Rumage says that teens started acting particularly mean to each other, accusing one another of starting the outbreak even though they didn’t know who was infected—the false outbreak is also bringing the topic of Texas’ sex education requirements to the national spotlight. Now, more attention is being paid to whether the classes (which are not required by law) should be integrated and whether abstinence-only education—the type required if sex ed is taught in Texas schools—is good enough.
The Crane school board will vote next week on a proposal to incorporate a sex ed class into local schools, a measure that Crane Independent School District’s curriculum director hopes will pass.
“This did make us aware that we need some kind of abstinence or sex ed program,” the director Yolanda Carr told me. The board voted against adding any program in April 2012, Carr said, because “it’s small town USA and they thought they didn’t need it.”
Even if the school board does vote to opt in for sexual education classes, the fact that they may be abstinence-only could be harmful to the teenagers who’d be taking them. In fact, according to Vice, the Texas school districts that do teach sex ed may be giving teens incorrect information to scare them away from intercourse.
“From our research we found very few districts actually do teach sex ed and the ones that teach abstinence-only give misleading information, like scare tactics about false failure rates of condoms,” Jose Medina, Texas Freedom Network’s communications director, told me. “Abstinence-only programs do not work and we’ve found that in our research.”
But the prevalence of abstinence-only education may be changing (if slowly). This month, a California judge ruled that teaching teens to wait for marriage does not count as fulfilling state sexual education requirements and does not provide students with “medically accurate” information about intercourse or its effects. While this ruling affects only about 40,000 students in the Clovis Unified School District, Think Progress makes the argument that it’s setting an important precedent for California and, hopefully, the rest of the nation.
Image via YouTube
Contact the author at [email protected].
- Results Uneven in Hong Kong’s Voluntary Sex-Ed Program
- City Recommends Teaching 'All Genders' Can Start Periods in Sex-Ed Equality Campaign
- Betsy DeVos: It’s time we balance the scales of justice in our schools
- School funding was on the ballot on Election Day. We can’t Pa’s kids down
- Here’s what working overseas taught me about improving American schools
- In his second term, Gov. Wolf has a chance to make Pa.'s public schools even stronger
- Boys High School Swimming Roundup: Cumberland Valley remains perfect in Mid-Penn Commonwealth action
- As sex-transmitted disease rates soar in Colo. and elsewhere, states beg for help
- As sex-transmitted disease rates soar in Colorado and elsewhere, states beg for help
- How To Start Having A Healthier And More Fulfilling Sex Life
- Deadly Hepatitis A Outbreaks Are Exposing Crumbling U.S. Public Health Infrastructure
- Teachers' Union to Bring Back Plan to Tax the Rich If State Doesn't Fund Schools
- Harvard’s War on Single-Sex Clubs Has Opened a New Battle Over Sex Discrimination
- Former Special Ed Teacher Charged After Allegedly Having Sex With Two Students
- The measles outbreak that just shouldn’t be
- Sexual harassment happens in elementary, middle and high schools. But not much is being done about it
- Sex education: Colorado bill would ban abstinence-only approach
- ‘Basis of Sex’ good but doesn’t do justice to RBG
- Central Pa. school district says it has resolved alleged racial slur by teacher, but doesn’t say how
- Bucknell research project writing the book on school's involvement in World War I
School With No Sex Ed Doesn't Have a Chlamydia Outbreak After All have 787 words, post on jezebel.com at May 13, 2015. This is cached page on Talk Vietnam. If you want remove this page, please contact us.