As a document of progressive aspirations, Bill de Blasio’s new housing plan is a beautiful thing. The 117-page report envisions a future in which seniors can stay put without fear of eviction, packed families can finally spread out, New York apartments get even more efficiently tiny, the homeless are given roofs of their own, and everyone who comes here can afford to stay. It’s exciting to see a new mayor throw the full weight of his office at the city’s most urgent problem: The rent is too damn high. This is more than just an economic document. De Blasio sees his housing plan as a tool to help desegregate the city, keep neighborhoods more stable but also mix up its income groups, and keep the middle class from spinning out into the inner-ring suburbs.
As my colleague Chris Smith discussed yesterday, the mayor is pumping real money into his immensely ambitious proposal: $8 billion in city funds that, multiplied by private investment and topped out with federal grants, should produce a $41 billion program, the largest ever. He’s baring some technocratic teeth, too: In many neighborhoods, private developers will be forced, not just politely asked, to include rent-regulated apartments in new buildings. He’s tailored policy to his dreams of lifting the poor: Subsidies tilt heavily towards the lower end of the economic spectrum. And he’s set a firm quota by to judge his tenure: 80,000 new affordable units in ten years, plus 120,000 more “preserved” — prevented from slipping away into the unregulated market.
But for now, “Housing New York” is more of a wish list than a plan. It promises future nuance and detail, but glosses over oppositions that could pit neighbors against each other, turning de Blasio’s “two cities” into a fistful of splinters.
Speed versus Consensus. A tone of urgency runs through the report’s bureaucratic prose, a sense that the housing crisis is flaring out of control. But no mayor can build by decree. Exactly where all those new apartments will be, in what sort of buildings, who will put them up, and how soon — those details will have to hammered out block by block in zoning maps, community board meetings, public brawls, and innumerable delays.
Density versus Gentrification. The word gentrification doesn’t appear once in the report, but it haunts all the policy prescriptions. In a city that is running out of land, building more means building high. To accomplish this, the de Blasio administration needs the real-estate market to thrive, but developers gravitate to areas where prices are on the way up. New towers include some rent-regulated units, but the rest heat up the local market, making the neighborhood less affordable, rather than more.
Idealism versus Realism. As the report points out, New York has a million poor households that compete for the roughly 425,000 apartments that they can afford. Even if all of the 80,000 new subsidized apartments went to that slice of the population, that still wouldn’t come close to making the city a less expensive place to live.
Neighborhood Stability versus Desegregation. An adequate stock of affordable apartments can help people keep living in the area where they grew up, and keep a neighborhood’s ethnic character from flaking away. But de Blasio has a conflicting goal, too: He sees his housing policy as a tool to help desegregate the city, mix up its income groups, and keep the middle class from spinning out to the inner-ring suburbs. How can you simultaneously encourage neighborhoods to change and also keep the same?
The Needy versus the Needier. The plan wisely addresses the epidemic in homelessness by emphasizing permanent supportive housing rather than emergency shelters. But it also hopes to foster a middle-class city that welcomes artists, houses more cops, and cuts down on teachers’ killer commutes. But subsidies are a zero-sum game, and one segment or another is bound to feel shortchanged. In fact, maybe all of them will.
Quantity versus Quality. Another word missing from the report is architecture. Unless design becomes a priority, the focus on building at a faster clip will produce a blight of shoddy uniformity that serves all of New York’s varied populations equally badly.
- The White House Plans to Reveal New AI Guidelines at CES 2020
- Demanding Answers: New Yorkers Skeptical Of Mayor De Blasio’s Street Homeless Action Plan
- Silent superhero Laser Beak Man, created by young boy with autism, takes Sydney Opera House stage
- Game of Thrones stars Alfie Allen and Mark Addy are reunited in violent drama White House Farm
- 'SNL' Comic Pete Davidson Addresses Ex Ariana Grande's NSFW Comment About Him: 'Everything Is Big to Her'
- 'Bring us back a keeper!' Rochelle Humes wishes her lookalike sister Sophie Piper, 21, 'good luck' ahead of her Love Island 2020 debut
- 'I don't think this should be happening to the Queen': Trump expresses his respect for the 'flawless' monarch as he wades into MEGXIT saying he thinks Harry and Meghan quitting is 'sad'
- House approves measure to restrain Trump’s actions on Iran
- Meghan Markle was 'on the brink': Prince Harry agreed to quit the Royal family and fast-tracked plans as he feared his 'unsettled' wife would have a 'meltdown' if she remained in the UK
- Live coverage: Pruitt faces grilling in House hearings
- The Ultimate Home-Buying Checklist: 12 Ways to Prepare to Buy a House
- Couple spend £165,000 converting 16th century cottage on George Clarke's Old House, New Home - but viewers claim husband can barely stand up straight in 'tiny' home (which doesn't even have a TV)
- 'Taking out a bad guy is not necessarily a good idea!' Pete Buttigieg says Donald Trump didn't consider consequences of killing Qassem Soleimani and is playing 'checkers' instead of '3-D chess'
- SEBASTIAN SHAKESPEARE: Was Meghan Markle's wedding wish a sermon by the Dalai Lama that was advised against by the Archbishop of Canterbury?
- Cheryl is branded a 'sperm bandit' and is slammed for 'denying kids a dad' by Fathers4Justice after revealing plans to expand her family with a donor as she fears 'time is running out'
- SHAPIRO: Bernie’s Plan To Crumble The Billionaire Class
- We live in the worst of times – but amid the darkness good things happened in 2018
- Social housing lacks land, cash
- U.K. House of Commons Needs More Women, Breastfeeding and Gender Neutral Toilets: Report
- Iran attacks two Iraqi bases housing US forces in 'revenge' for Soleimani's death
Davidson: How the de Blasio Housing Plan Is Good, If Wishful, Thinking have 1059 words, post on nymag.com at May 6, 2014. This is cached page on Talk Vietnam. If you want remove this page, please contact us.