We’re guessing you’ve read about the internet battle raging between Tesla CEO Elon Musk and The New York Times reporter John M. Broder. If not, a quick, hyperlinked recap: Broder writes a story on his largely unsuccessful attempt to drive a Tesla Model S from Washington, D.C. to Boston using Tesla’s network of Supercharger stations. Elon Musk tweets, “NYTimes article about Tesla range in cold is fake. Vehicle logs tell true story that he didn’t actually charge to max & took a long detour.” Broder defends. Musk attacks. Broder defends. News outlets covering everything from business to technology have picked up the story.
We feel for Broder. He is being called a liar. His defenses of his article are strong, as is Musk’s attack. Will any concrete truth come out of this he-said, he-said battle? Unlikely. But there are some further details that we would like to know.
For starters, it isn’t clear what tires were on the car. Broder says the Model S was on all-seasons, yet summer rubber was the defined spec for his test car. If the all-season tires had a larger overall diameter than the specified summer tires, the speedometer in the dash would have indicated lower speeds than the car was actually traveling, thus cutting into the range and the range modeling. (Most car speedos are off by a few mph, however.)
Which brings us to our second question: What “speed” is Musk quoting? Vehicle ECUs log individual wheel speeds and driveshaft speed (the one that dictates speedometer readings), and we wouldn’t doubt it if cars log GPS-based speeds, too. Is Musk’s speed the same speed displayed in the dash during Broder’s drive?
If Musk is using GPS speed in his argument and the tire size is off, then Musk’s claims of Broder saying he was driving slower than he actually was are bogus. Or, if the tire size is significantly off, and the car was indeed going faster than indicated, Broder isn’t to blame.
- Full Test: 2013 Tesla Model S
- Photos and Info: Tesla Model X Crossover
- Instrumented Test: 2011 Tesla Roadster Sport
We would love to see other data charts, such as state-of-charge versus time. The raw data would be even better, as we could zoom in on specific sections of Broder’s trip and analyze how all the parameters interact with one another.
We’re intrigued, although there’s little point in speculating on every last aspect of both parties’ claims. We’ve reached out to Broder and Tesla for comment and they have yet to respond. We’ll keep you posted as details unfold.
- Inside The New York Times as it debates its coverage of Trump and racism
- Mira Nair to adapt New York Times article ‘The Jungle Prince of Delhi’ in a series
- Talking to Jason Zinoman, the New Comedy Critic for the New York Times
- NBC’s Seth Meyers Shames New York Times for Running Tom Cotton’s ‘Fascist’ Op-Ed
- New York Times publisher responds to staff outrage over Tom Cotton op-ed
- Liberty U. Files $10 Million Defamation Suit Against New York Times
- New York Times: Trump considered selling Puerto Rico following Hurricane Maria, former acting Homeland Security chief says
- New York Times senior editor resigns amid backlash over controversial op-ed
- New York Times says senator Tom Cotton's op-ed did not meet editorial standards
- Bari Weiss Resigns From New York Times Decrying “Constant Bullying” By Colleagues Who Disagree With Her
- Claim: Ancestors of New York Times Family Included Slave Owners, Confederate Supporters
- Michael Goodwin: Bari Weiss resignation latest example of New York Times' decline
- Bari Weiss quits New York Times after bullying by colleagues: 'They have called me a Nazi and a racist'
- READ: Bari Weiss announces she's leaving New York Times in scathing resignation letter
- Rose McGowan slams New York Times reporter over alleged Tara Reade questions
- Liberal journalists dismiss, mock Bari Weiss' departure from The New York Times
- Harris Faulkner reflects on Bari Weiss resignation from New York Times: 'Diversity helps us win'
- CNN, MSNBC avoid on-air coverage of Bari Weiss' dramatic exit from The New York Times
- Bari Weiss' resignation letter proves New York Times engaging in 'outright censorship,' critic says
- Bari Weiss quits New York Times with scathing open resignation letter
Tesla vs. The New York Times: What We’d Like to Know have 697 words, post on blog.caranddriver.com at February 15, 2013. This is cached page on Talk Vietnam. If you want remove this page, please contact us.